Jump to content


Members Plus
  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

horseshoes's Achievements

  1. Why would you want your cook to take longer if the product isn’t actually better?
  2. I would agree that washing the inside of your grill with soap and water after every use is weird. But I have to disagree with the last post. If you don’t taste charcoal at all, you have no tastebuds. Cooking over charcoal of any kind imparts an absolutely unmistakable flavor. It should not be strong, but the flavor is night and day compared to something like an oven or gas grill.
  3. FWIW, I’ve used a lot of KJ lump since starting the thread and have not had this issue with other bags. I don’t know what it was, but I have not done anything different before or after. Other than I have only had the bags since then (not boxes). I can only assume something weird happened to the lump in that box. I also gave up pretty quickly on breaking up big pieces, doesn’t seem to matter, but now that I think about it, it does seem like there are far fewer giant pieces in the big 30lb bags. So maybe the huge log theory isn’t totally ruled out. My current bags were from costco (finally got a hold of them there) and were pretty well handled in their lifetime. All of them had rips in the bottom and had to be put in garbage bags to get them out of the store without leaving a black trail. The other difference, as I think was pointed out, is the boxed version has some kind of feed bag inside holding the charcoal, vs the bag version only being the big paper bag. I don’t know if that would matter though.
  4. I’m kind of worried about how easily it might reach 500 being so close to the heat with a lot of charcoal and no deflector. The dome thermometer won’t be a useful way to tell how hot it’s getting underneath. Remember, it’s not cooks that have to be below 500, it’s the sloroller itself. I guess you could always keep a bird nearby. If it dies, you’re cooking the teflon! Still showing as out of stock though.
  5. So, are they ever going to sell this thing? They said it would be available for Classic II quite a while ago.
  6. Well, another update. I found a Lowes with the bagged version of KJ lump, and grabbed a bag. Had 2 cooks on it now, seems to be fine. So this suggests that maybe the first box did have something nasty going on that required extremely long pre-burning to get rid of. I am actually finding KJ mixed with Royal Oak to be a good combo. Since the RO is much smaller, it fills in the gaps that the giant KJ blocks leave, which helps things light faster and packs the firebox more full for longer cooks. I have the KJ ash basket and usually use a Fireboard with fan, so there is still plenty of airflow. @John Setzler, if you still want to check out this "bad batch", send me a PM and we can arrange something.
  7. Well, drove 1.5 hour round trip to the road show and no KJ to be found. Asked an employee and they got a manager, who said that the KJ reps were a no show for the entire event. So, no lump for me! The manager at Costco said they may not be allowed back, because apparently this has been an issue, and they don’t take kindly to flakey vendors. Come on Kamado Joe, get your #### together...
  8. 1. Yeah, tried the smell test, and although the smell improved by the time I usually put it on, I questioned whether or not it still smelled right. I did think it was a little off, but was second guessing myself. I would say that it didn’t smell so bad that a less experienced user could immediately conclude that it was awful, but it didn’t smell great either. Although I had some doubts that the smell was where it needed to be, the color/thickness combined with running it for over an hour and a half, made me feel relatively confident that this had to be as good as it gets. 2. Grabbing pieces by hand and setting them in, plus in subsequent cooks, some lump that was reclaimed.
  9. Indeed, I'm a relatively new grill owner, and using the same logic, I've been puzzling over it going back and forth between both explanations. Didn't really make sense to me that it would be bad lump, and it doesn't happen with RO. But now I have a very interesting update to this! I made a couple of steaks last night. There were some very large chunks (much bigger than fist sized), and although I tried to break them a little bit, I didn't have a hatchet handy. I made a point of trying to ensure that the fire really got going, and for longer than usual. Instead of using the electric heating element starter, I lit 3 lighter cubes, gave it plenty of oxygen, burning with the dome open for about 20 minutes, then with the dome closed but the vents wide open for a while, and then started to close them a bit to bring it down to temperature. Total burn time before I put any food on was over an hour and a half. When it got to about 320 degrees, I decided to throw the steaks on, cooked them indirect to medium well/well done (accidentally overshot). They tasted pretty bad. Still edible, since steaks are a bit more tolerant than something like fish or chicken to smoke, but it was like a delicious steak flavor wrapped in a dirty aroma and flavor of smoke that was unmistakeable. Since I overcooked them, and the wife wasn't home yet, and I am too much of a perfectionist to serve a well done steak, I threw 2 more on. Still had plenty of charcoal and I just let it keep going. Easily burning for a couple of hours by this point. By this time, the temp had cooled to about 260-275, so I cooked them again and they went quite a bit longer, in theory, absorbing more smoke. They tasted amazing. Nothing like the first 2. Wife got home just as they hit medium rare and she loved it. Just for science, I cut a small piece from the least well done side of the original batch and put it on her plate. Night and day difference, she confirmed it tasted bad. I saved a bit of leftovers in the fridge from both, and tried them again this afternoon. One is still great tasting, one is unmistakably the putrid smoke one. To me this confirms what was posted above - too young a fire for charcoal that is too big. Even though I was well aware of this concept in theory, and thought 1 hour+ had to be plenty, that isn't necessarily the case. But, switching to Royal Oak, which as was pointed out is much smaller, it makes sense that following the same procedure for both would produce great results with RO but putrid garbage with giant XL logs in the firebox. It isn't obvious that your choices for dealing with the exceptionally large pieces are either: burn for over 2 hours, or take a hatchet to the pieces, so it's no wonder that some people have this experience and don't know why. Now I have to head to that costco road show, stock up on the 30lb bags while I can, and pick up a hatchet from home depot on the way back So I'm curious then, folks who use KJ XL regularly, do you always hack up the big pieces? I suppose a chimney starter likely avoids the issue as well, since they're pretty effective at burning lump up quickly, but I just find them too awkward and inconvenient to use and handle with a KJ. If anyone is not breaking up their big pieces and not having this problem, I'd be curious what your lighting method is... Edited to add: I also wonder if there is less potential for the really large pieces among those who buy the 30lb bags vs the 20lb boxes. Bags are prone to getting lump crushed during shipping/handling, boxes are immune to that problem. That's my biggest problem with the RO bags - the size of the larger pieces is pretty good, but it seems like a lot get crushed into chips and dust that settles as you get near the bottom.
  10. Sure, I have maybe 1/8th of the box left, if you want the remains. I ordered it from Amazon a few weeks ago (Seattle area). The Costco road show is here this week, so I think I'll grab one more box from there and see if the results are any different. Maybe I'll wait to see how that turns out, and then contact you for shipping info.
  11. You load it up to the handles? So lump is basically right below the grate in the top position? How do you use a heat deflector?
  12. Why might one want to cook salmon below 200 F? I’ve tried Salmon many different ways, and have not really noticed a difference when I vary the temp, other than taking longer. But I’m pretty new to this, so just curious if there is a benefit that I’m not aware of.
  • Create New...