Jump to content

Andy B

Members Plus
  • Posts

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


Everything posted by Andy B

  1. I have done hundreds of racks of ribs over the years on various smokers. They are my favorite thing to cook and eat. I can tell you for a fact that 225 is too low. I find 250 to make a big difference. Also wrapping is crucial. If you want a firmer rib with more resistance wrap in butcher paper to keep them from steaming themselves. This will speed up your cook while still retaining moisture.
  2. I’ve gone about 8 hours. You might be able to get 10 if you really load it up with premium quality charcoal. And you absolutely need a charcoal basket to maintain a steady temperature for that long on a joe jr.
  3. It’s about 18-20” wide and deep. About 24” tall including the small pallet it sits on.
  4. If you have found where to get this yet please let me know. I need one!
  5. Thanks for the reply. I took everything out and I can lift the unit on my own. The tricky part is going to be dropping it into the base without getting my hand caught. I do like the lift strap idea. I might be able to make that work
  6. So I’m moving to another state and my new house is in the middle of nowhere. I don’t know anyone there that could help me unload my kamado joe classic 1 and my only neighbors are an elderly couple so I don’t want to ask them. It will be loaded into the back of my pickup truck so it’s fairly high off the ground. I can pull up to the spot that I want to keep it. Does anyone have any suggestions as to how to get it from my truck into the base?
  7. I’m sure there are a lot of opinions out there but here is mine. I’d go with the classic 2 over the big joe 1. The reason why I say this is because I have a classic and the only time I’ve ever wished I had a big joe is to do a whole big packer brisket. Separate the flat and point, problem solved. Another reason I say go for the classic is the heat up/cool down time. I also have a joe jr and that thing heats up twice as fast as my classic. I imagine the big joe would be considerably slower to come up to temp than the classic. The only reason I’d say to get the big joe is if you’re regularly cooking for more than 10 people. Another opinion of mine is the huge price difference between the classic 1 and 2 is definitely not worth it. I have classic 1 and never once have I said, “I wish this lid wasn’t so heavy”. That is the biggest difference between the two and it cost $500 more for it. The kontrol tower is like $50 if you really wanted it but the daisy wheel works just as well. I think you should get the classic 1 and use all the money you save to get a kick ash basket and build a proper table. That is unless you are feeding a large group on a regular basis, then go for the big joe.
  8. Does anybody know where I could find something that would work as a half moon heat deflector for a Joe Jr? Before anyone says just get a classic, I already have one. I find myself using my jr a lot more than I thought I would and it would be nice to have two heat zones when cooking a couple burgers or a single steak.
  9. So the problem was definitely that I needed to thaw the steaks before cooking. I thought I could get two birds stoned at once and just throw a frozen steak on there but I was wrong. Perfect results on the first try.
  10. Thomas, I’m not saying they were bad they were actually quite good. I just don’t understand why the price is so astronomical for a steak you could get anywhere else. I’m sure they do have good sales and discounts, but even at half price they are still charging double what you should pay. I buy from several different small time butchers that sell wagyu for less than they charge. For example, here is a wagyu outside skirt steak I picked up from a butcher in Cleveland called Mister Brisket. I wanna say I paid around $25 a pound for this last year. It’s a great operation they run there and they ship all over the country. I encourage anyone reading this to look them up. And then there’s Sam’s club. They currently charge about $18 a pound for ridiculously good steaks. I can even get A4 Japanese wagyu from a local butcher for around $100 a pound if I really want to splurge. I just can’t in good conscience recommend anyone buy steaks from the Chicago steak company when there are so many other options to buy better quality meat for a fraction of the price.
  11. I got a gift certificate for my birthday for the Chicago steak company. I was skeptical of the legitimacy of the company after seeing their website claiming to sell Kobe flat iron steaks. I ordered a dozen wagyu burgers, which were great although way overpriced, and two 8 oz premium angus ribeyes. The steaks were an astonishing $89 a pound so I was expecting a lot. The shipping was good and everything was still frozen solid when I arrived. They did not look great when I thawed them and one of them as pretty brown. I seasoned them with just salt and pepper to be able to really judge the quality of the meat. I threw them on the joe jr at about 700 degrees as they were pretty thin and didn’t want to over cook them too bad. So I have to say I’m pretty disappointed. They were delicious don’t get me wrong. But it was not any better than a good hand picked steak from your local grocery store for under $20 a pound. I would have been absolutely livid if I hadn’t bought them with a gift card. At $89 a pound you may as well spend a little more and get imported wagyu. Or run to your local butcher that sells usda prime and pick some up for a quarter to half the price of these. So my point is that if you run across these guys and think you’re going to spoil yourself or someone you may give them to as a gift, don’t. There are plenty of other online butchers out there that sell better quality beef at much more reasonable prices. This company is nothing but fancy advertising and hype.
  12. Sam’s club has prime beef at better prices than most grocery stores charge for choice. Last time I was there prime ribeyes were $17 a pound and prime brisket was $5.50 and those prices were unusually high.
  13. Thanks for the replies. I hadn’t really thought of thickness impacting doneness. The ribeyes I usually cook are about 16 ounces and probably about an inch thick. Maybe that’s my problem. I’ll pick up a tomahawk ribeye next time I’m at sams club and give that a go. Also going to try not starting with a frozen steak and see if that makes any difference.
  14. I have been trying with little success to reverse sear on both my kamados. I start with a preheated grill at 200-225, heat deflector in place, and throw on a frozen steak. Slowly let it come up to about 90-100 degrees and pull it off. Open the vents all the way and sear it once the grill is 600+ degrees. I’m shooting for medium rare so I pull it off when it hits 120. Every single time it has come out way overdone. I’m using a thermapen so I know that’s not the problem. I make steaks in the sous vide all the time and they always come out perfect. I don’t understand how this is much different from that process. Could starting with a frozen steak be the cause? Any advice?
  15. If you’re not using a charcoal basket you need to get one. It made an enormous difference in the way my jr performs. I’ve had mine 500+ with the deflector in place and it could have easily went higher. Also using fresh charcoal makes a world of difference.
  16. I thought the same thing when I first got my joe classic. Give it some time and I think you will come to prefer the half moons. They’re easy to lift out with the divide and conquer rack, and the ability to have dual heat zones because of the split deflectors is what makes Kamado Joes so great. I recently picked up a joe jr and I’m honestly disappointed it doesn’t have half moon deflectors.
  17. Update: I ended up buying the joe jr. and I am in love with it. There is just something fun about cooking on a tiny grill. I find it easier to fire up and cook 3 burgers or sear a steak out of the sous vide, which I do a lot. It gets so hot so quick compared to the classic. I can see it coming in handy when I do larger cooks for guests as well. I still do use my classic a lot though and love them both equally. Now all I need is for a big joe 1 to go on clearance at Lowe’s, and my wife to allow me to buy it, so I can have all three.
  18. I am going to build a rolling table for a Kamado Joe classic and jr. I want to integrate some sort of roof. I was thinking something that would fold down to act as a cover when not in use. Sort of like an awning. Has anyone on here built anything like what I’m thinking of? I searched all over and couldn’t find anything.
  19. I appreciate the replies. I think I’ll just spend the money on a jotisserie and dojoe and enjoy the classic I have. I’ll still eventually get a big joe when I can convince my wife that I need it and forget about the joe jr. thank you guys for keeping me from wasting money!
  20. I fully understand the grate temp is going to be higher but 60 degrees difference is not right. Maybe if I had the deflector in and running at 400+ degrees I would expect a fairly large variation but at 225 and having 12 hours to even out something is wrong. I actually contacted Kamado Joe customer service yesterday and got an automated email response saying they were sending me a new thermometer. The fact that they have an automated response to this claim in place indicates this is a common problem with these. I am considering buying a teltru to compare it against.
  21. I tested mine against my ThermaQ and the grate temp was 60 degrees higher than the dome temp throughout a 12 hour low and slow cook. It sounds like Kamado Joe is slacking in the quality of their thermometers. I haven’t contacted them about it yet but I intend to.
  22. I have not. Thank you for sharing. It looks very informative!
  23. I just purchased my classic 1 a few weeks ago. I am absolutely in love with it. I will be getting a big joe at some point in the future. But for some reason I have an urge to get the jr too. I usually am only cooking for 3. I like the idea of being able to fire up a grill fast just to throw a few burgers or steaks on but I need to know will it really be that much faster to start and cool down than the classic? Is it big enough for 3 large ribeyes? Has anyone bought one and regretted it? They have them at bj’s wholesale club for $299 and I can’t stop thinking about buying one. Somebody please talk me out of it.
  24. Hello everyone my name is Andy. I just bought my first real kamado, a Kamado Joe classic 1. I had an akorn years ago but never really had it dialed in. I have been visiting this sight for about a month and figured it was time to join. Im excited to learn more about how to use this thing. I’ve had many gas and charcoal grills, pellet, electric and offset smokers, and a blackstone griddle.
  • Create New...