Jump to content

March Challenge----Peyton Manning steaks


Recommended Posts

The weather on this relaxing Sunday can only be described as glorious.  



Yesterday was cruddy-cold-rainy.....but today......sunny & almost 80 degrees.  Unreal.



Figured I'd have some fun in the backyard with the grill.  Things were smelling great out there.



Thanks to this challenge, things were smelling good inside, too, as I was moved outa my comfort zone of using store-bought sauces.



The results were to my tribe's liking, too.   They asked for the sauce again on other cooks....wings, ribs, chops and others.  I will oblige their requests. I liked the sauce, too.



The keys to this sauce, imho, are the freshly ground & chopped ingredients.













This was an on-the-fly recipe that I will tweak and continue to use.  Texted it to some buddies who were either grilling or soon to be. 






Sauce-making music was enjoyed !







Very grateful to have these cuts in the freezer thanks to Mom & Dad's thoughtfulness at Christmas.  Excellent gift that was appreciated by everyone today !!!!















I also mastered the art of untying that first pesky knot that allows a ridiculously easy bag opening. :good:







Set the Big Joe up with the Divide & Conquer system for some two zone cooking for the stuffed potatoes & steaks.









Molly took up a spot downwind of the grill and seemed to really enjoy the relaxing afternoon.










Gave them a good dusting with some great KJ flavors.







Krunk it on up when the potatoes were close to done.










Went with the thicker cuts first.








Seared the thinner filets next and then moved them all over to the cool side to rest and finish reaching the internal temps I was shooting for.










If ribs, wings and chops are better with sauce......why not steaks ?




Got a bowl of the sauce grillside and slathered it on the steaks when they were about 10 degrees from being ready.













Roasted corn & asparagus with a small amount of the KJ good stuff. :good:


































The verdict is in:      The sauce was killer.  I'm glad the challenge gave me the nudge to homebrew my own.    




The verdict is also in......we are all stuffed and chillaxing.   Molly has be pinned down as I type this. :rofl:






Link to comment
Share on other sites

Oh yeah! Those steaks were perfectly cooked. :respect: The sides look great and that sauce looked killer. :good::woot:

The only thing wrong with this cook was that I wasn't invited. :rofl:




Thanks !



I've been making my steaks the exact same way for the past two years (since discovering about Paymaster's method) and my family loves it.




I figured for a sauce to be good.....it should stand up and complement anything.    I took a risk and deviated on my normal way of doing steaks and the sauce was a huge hit on them and the potatoes.


I don't think it's the kind of sauce that I can bottle and save due to the ingredients.....but it's easy enough to make.   I'll certainly use it on other types of cooks, too. 



I'm grateful that this challenge pushed me out of my normal ways of doing things.  I'm one of those "If it ain't broke....don't fix it !" types.   This was fun.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dang it Dub - you went all out with this sauce and the cook in general. Very nice entry.

A good sauce compliments not only the steak but the dinner in general. I use to be like you - a bit of rub/seasoning but a naked steak none the less. Lately I've been doing wet marinades and sauces for a steak cook. It can really take it over the top.

My only question - Why didn't I get a text.? I would have tried it on my shoulder cook tonight.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thank you everyone.


You folks are way too kind.   This was a really easy cook that I thoroughly enjoyed doing on this super afternoon.



I feel like I grew up a little bit on this cook.   It's the first steak cook in ages that I didn't go near-nuclear on the sear temps.  The split firebox worked great in conjunction with the D&C racks letting me get it down low over the coals.  I felt like I had plenty of room and having a "cold" side was really a luxury, too.  I was able to temp check each steak with ease without having to remove the steaks first. 


The other thing is  that this sauce was truly all-purpose, too.  Easy to make and a flavor that I could see working killer on chicken.










How are the steaks from there????  Never had one......  Looks great!



They were really good.   


Sure were convenient, too.  




The package we received had a variety of stuff in it:   steaks, chicken breasts, burgers, hot dogs and stuffed potatoes.







Each of the boxes contains vacuum sealed single portions.  These potatoes were able to be cooked from a frozen state.  Super easy.



I feel the quality of the steaks was really good.  The 5 oz sirloin cubes, were, in fact, the best sirloins I've had.  The filets were very tender....no knife needed.  One cool thing is that I almost always buy ribeyes and this offered a refreshing change.  


I don't know that I'll be reordering any time soon....unless the price is right.....but it sure was mighty nice being able to skip a shopping trip and just go to the garage freezer instead.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Similar Content

    • By GrillDawg
      Fired up the KJ for some NY Strip Steaks last night. I'd have to say...best steak I've had, hands down.
      Got the steaks from a Stripling's General Store here in town. Seasoned with some Lane's BBQ Brisket rub. Put a block of Hickory in the fire.
      1. Got the grill up to around 300º while seasoning.

      2. First time using my ThermoPro wireless thermometer. It definitely gave me the flexibility of hanging out inside while getting up to temp!

      3. Got the steaks to 125º and pulled them off and tented with aluminum foil.

      4. Opened up the vents and aimed to get to 550-600º for the sear.

      5. "I have made fire!"

      6. Looking tasty! It smelled so good.

      7. Plated with some spinach salad and a twice baked potato from Striplings.

      8. Look at that color!

      I'd have to say...this is my fourth cook on my KJ since buying it for Father's Day and everything I make on it is amazing. My wife looked at my across the table while eating and said, "I see why you wanted to spend so much money on a grill. This is delicious!"
      If only she would have that logic when I try to convince her I want to buy a truck...haha
    • By David Scubadiver
      I purchased my grill in December and finally got around to using it Sunday afternoon.  I have been cooking sous vide and using a cast iron pan lately, but the smoke has been terrible. 
      For or my first time grilling,  I decided on baked potatoes, steaks and asparagus. Started the fire with a twisted paper towel wetted with vegetable oil. 
      The fire got hotter than intended, and stayed hotter than intended.  I started with the potatoes and let them cook for nearly an hour above the heat deflector. Then I added the raw steaks, and eventually the asparagus that were prepared with some oil and seasoning.
      I was prepared for disaster but everything came out delicious. I forgot to open up the vents for the sear, but as I said, the grill was hot. 

    • By ryantt
      Well I finally got a chance to fire up the kj classic, but no time for a low and slow.   I cooked a few steaks 450ish until almost done, the. Dropped them done close to the coals and finished them off.  
      So what did I think of my new kj.  Initially when I got it I felt it may be Of lesser quality, and I happy to report I was wrong.  It heated up like a rocket, held steady and shut down like a champ.....even with out the ceramic cap.  

      Thanks for looking. 
    • By THATGUY
      The other day I solicited inputs for my Brazilian themed Olympic Cookout.  @Andyscalzo had lot of great suggestions, but the one that really stuck with me was his recommendation on how to do pineapple.  It just so happens I had a very sober pineapple sitting on my counter the other day and a grill that was still hot outside, so I figured I would give it a shot.  Andy had given me an outline to follow, but I went to Mike Vrbet at Dadcooksdinner for a few more details.  My approach ended up being a hybrid of the two based on materials.  Andy recommended I use a cherry rub, but I didn't have one of those in my pantry. 
      1) Chop off crown and base of pineapple
      2) Peel the Pineapple but cutting off the peel with 6—8 cuts
      3) Inject the pineapple with a rum of your choice (I used Trader Vic’s Dark Rum and this is why I call it “Drunken Pineapple”)
      4) Sprinkle turbinado sugar on the pineapple flesh
      5) Spear the pineapple through the core with the spit and install forks
      6) Install rotisserie on a hot grill
      7) Cook for approximately 30 minutes, until the caramelization reaches desired level.
      8) Slice thinly down the length of the pineapple and serve
      I sliced it thinly and served with a vanilla macadamia nut ice cream that is made locally.  I even added a splash or two of rum, it was delicious.  Big thanks to Andy for the suggestion, I had grilled pineapple before but never like this and it was a good opportunity to take the Joetisserie for another spin. 
      Photos here
    • By DerHusker
      Last week they put Ribeye Roasts on sale for $6.99 a lb. and $5.88 a lb. if you purchased $25.00 of other items.  This is a great price so I went in to buy a roast and they didn’t have any good looking ones out in the display case so I asked for one from the back. They brought out a whole rib to cut me one. When I saw it I told them I’d just buy the whole thing. Here it is in the cryovac plastic. (Approx. 21” long and 22 lbs.)




      It was so big I cut it in half for easier handling.

      Oooh! Nice color.  

      I cut it into approximate 3” thick, bone-in steaks.


      I kept one out for immediate use and vacuum packed the rest for future meals.

      Oh yeah!  
  • Create New...