Jump to content

Golden's Cast Iron Kamado Review request


Recommended Posts

I may eventually be in the market for a second kamado (I own the Blaze aluminum kamado and love it), and wanted to know if anyone owns the Golden's cast iron kamado. If anyone owns this kamado or knows someone with the kamado, would you mind giving an update? I assume that this kamado cooks quite evenly (considering its mass) since my Blaze performers so well. I am a huge fan of anything made of cast iron, but was curious how easy it was to get the Golden's to pizza/searing temperature (600+ degrees). I made pizzas the other night on my blaze and think I did not add enough charcoal for a total of (4) pizzas to stay at 550-600 on a cool night; I blew through all of my charcoal quiskly. Also, has anyone smoked something like a brisket (12 plus hours) and noticed much temperature variance (My blaze does quite well). 


Why do I want a second kamado you ask?

1. Because I want to be able to cook multiple meats at different temps at the same time, or perhaps smoke one thing while using the rotisserie on the Blaze.  

2. I want to be able to cook a lot of food (I enjoy cooking for others) 

3. I'm a like a kid with his toys; my toys now revolve around food and beer... 



Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not sure I've seen anyone post that they own a CI kamado although I think there is a post about them on here somewhere. 


As for multiple kamados - most of us understand the need for that. I currently have 3 ;)



Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

I own one and love it. Have made pizzas several times that came out great. (full disclosure, I'm part of the company that makes them in Columbus GA!)


As for totally independent experiences on Golden's Cast Iron Cooker, you might want to check out some of Lunchman's posts on BBQ-Bretheren. There are others out there as well.


Good luck!


Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...
  • 5 months later...

I realize this request for a review of a Goldens' Cast Iron Cooker goes back quite a bit, but I figured I'd start off as a new member of the forum with a review. I've had the grill about a year and a half, ordered directly from the Goldens' Foundry in Columbus GA. Before ordering, I called the folks at Goldens', they graciously answered all my questions about the cooker and I knew that this was a company and family I wanted to do business with. I had some issues with the first grill delivered (all shipping company problems), one of the VPs at Goldens' called me directly and said they were shipping me a new cooker, no questions asked. I don't think I've ever had customer service like that from any company. 


Here are some pics of the cooker in my garage shortly after delivery -




Single piece cast iron firebox with the optional divider plate (used for two zone cooks) -




Cast iron half grates. The grates have legs on them, can be turned upside down to get closer to the fire or stacked as in this photo for additional grilling surface. Even with just two grates installed, one can be legs up, the other legs down which allows for a nice reverse sear -




Searing plate / heat diffuser. Similar to a BGE platesetter, but a bit more versatile as it can be used for searing. I've only recently used it for searing, the results were fabulous -




Lower vent control -




Upper vent and thermometer -




Normal grate height -







The usual questions:


Does it rust? No. It took all of one cook to season the inside, no worries about it ever rusting. The outside is powder coated, nothing to worry about there either. 


Does the outside get hot? Yes, but no hotter than a ceramic Kamado. Don't put your hands on it, but it's not scorching hot where you'd be worried about burns if you touched it.


Does it take long to heat up? No longer than a ceramic Kamado. Usually once I light my lump it's ready for cooking in about 20 minutes. 


Does it take long to cool down? Nope, within an hour or two it's dropped its temp where it doesn't register on the thermometer.


Weight? 330 lbs, plus the cart which is around another 100-125 or so. Easily wheeled around on my deck, but this isn't a cooker you're going to take tailgating. I opted for the smaller of the two carts, I didn't need the larger cart with the side shelves. Goldens' does make a smaller 14" cooker.


Diameter: 20.5" cooking surface. Plenty of room.


My experience with this cooker has been fantastic. Coming from the Bubba Keg the learning curve was minimal, mainly getting used to the vent controls which took about 2 or 3 cooks. It's easy to cook on and quite versatile. I'll never have to worry about a Humpty Dumpty moment with this cooker. It'll last forever and in 500 years someone will be grilling on it.


That's it for this quick review. Any questions, feel free to ask.





Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 5 months later...
6 hours ago, Lensi said:

What's it like to sear when the cooking grill is lower closer to the fire?

It works quite well. If I'm doing a sear (or reverse sear) I normally use the divider plate and put the lower grate on the hot side of the grill, cooking over the indirect side. With the upside down grate being a bit closer to the coals, it gives a nice sear. It's only closer to the fire by the height of the legs but it works well.


I recently posted a Rib Eye steak cook that was done using this method; it was exceptional. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
  • 2 weeks later...
On 3/10/2019 at 6:34 PM, shuley said:

Awesome review.  Do you wheel it out of the rain?  Does it need a cover? 

Nope, it stays outside and has easily survived two New England winters with no issues.  I do have a poorly fitting cover for it left over from a gas grill,  but I don't always cover it.  Goldens' does make a cover for the larger cart but not for this one. 


Pretty much the only reason I cover it is the Bubba Keg and Weber Kettle both have covers, so the Goldens' might as well have one also. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 3/10/2019 at 7:04 PM, dj-ia said:

I also have both the mini and full cart version.   They are both amazing and cook very well.  I have owned Kamado joes big and classic along with a mini Max as well s a KK 23”.  Love them all and love the CI cookers also 


Wow,  you're the first other Goldens' owner I've ever run into on any forum. You own the 14" cooker? I assume it behaves the same as our larger ones? Pics?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

41 minutes ago, lunchman said:


Wow,  you're the first other Goldens' owner I've ever run into on any forum. You own the 14" cooker? I assume it behaves the same as our larger ones? Pics?


Yes we would love to see pictures of all 6 kamados you have owned ;)


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Similar Content

    • By itskrod00
      Want to purchase one of these accessories.  My question is can the soap stone do everything the cast iron can do plus more?
      I imagine the soapstone wouldnt get as hot as the cast iron?
      I imagine the cast iron cooking, more food would possibly stick and more maintenance
      are they too very different tools for different type cooks/food.
    • By Churchill Fan
      For those of you using the cast iron or soapstone cooking surface on your KJ, do you use a half-moon or full-moon? That is to say, to you make a complete flat top or just a half? 
      Just curious as to what the prevailing custom is. Thanks!
    • By tmc
      Just saw this: Blaze will be increasing their prices 18% (due to import tariffs) on July 16th. So if you want a Blaze whatever, now's the time. 
      (I am not affiliated with Blaze in the slightest. This is just a PSA)
    • By John Setzler
      I was fortunate enough to get to partner with Wicked Edge to demo and evaluate this sharpening system.  I have been playing with it a good bit this week to learn how it works and get the diamond stones broken in and ready to get down to business...

      This is the Wicked Edge WE-130 mounted on their aluminum base.  This base is 8"x10"x1" and it weights about 8 pounds to give the sharpener good stability on whatever work surface you choose.  They also have a 12"x10"x1.25" granite base option that weighs about 15lbs if you want something heavier.  The sharpener also comes with a template for the mounting screw holes so you can make your own base out of whatever material you like if you want to.  The bases are optional and do not come with the sharpener kit.

      The sharpening angle adjustments on each side of the WE-130 go from 13° to 35° in 1° increments.  The small set screw on the right edge of the arm base allows you to micro adjust between 1° settings if you are using the optional digital angle gauge.  See later photos....

      This cam arm is an update from previous versions of the wicked edge.  When you position your blade in the holder,  you just lower this arm to create the tension to hold it rather than using a hex key to tighten it in place.  

      The blade holder holds up to a 3/16" thick blade.  There is an optional attachment for 1/4" thick blades if needed.

      The WE-130 kit comes with 100/200 and 400/600 grit diamond stones for sharpening.  For most applications that is completely sufficient.  Wicked Edge provided me with the 800/1000 grit diamond stones and the 5/3.5 micron diamond paste leather strops also.  Wicked Edge offers a vast array of additional stones and strops if you are more interested in being able to produce a super high polished mirror edge on your blade bevels.  I don't mess with that level of detail on my kitchen knives but I enjoy having it on my pocket knives.  I will likely be adding a couple of their ceramic stones to this collection in the near future.  

      You can also get a digital angle gauge if you are interested in absolute perfection of the angle and I would also consider this a requirement if you want to use the add-on low angle adapter to get angles below 13°.  I have a collection of Dalstrong Shogun series knives that I intend to sharpen with this unit and they have bevels in the 10° range that I want to be able to maintain.  

      For todays' photo session and testing, I got out my Columbia River Knife and Tool (CRKT) Lake Design Thunderbolt 2 knife.  This is a tanto style blade that takes a little extra attention when sharpening, but the Wicked edge handled it perfectly.  This knife lives in my Man Cave and it's primary function cutting open boxes and bags of charcoal.  It takes a beating.  This was a cheap knife (about $20 or so) and it has held up to several years of pretty hard abuse.  

      I used the digital angle gauge on this knife just to familiarize myself with the operation of the adjustments.  I would not normally care for that much precision on a knife like this.  I like 21-24° bevels on my pocket knifes normally.  They hold their edge and stay sharp much longer with a wider angle bevel.  
      My next project with this is to make some video on the process of actually setting this up and sharpening some knives.  I have two kitchen knives I have been saving to sharpen on video with this.  The two knives are my Henckels Zwilling Pro 4" paring knife and 8" chef's knife.   I haven't used those knives in a while but both of them are in bad need of a good sharpening.  

    • By DiannaDZ
      Just purchased a 12 inch Lodge cast iron skillet at Home Depot for $19.99.  Pretty good price, 2 Handle so it should fit in most kamado type grills.
  • Create New...