Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Hi, I followed the steps in this video
and I my brisket turned out dry and dense. I'm hoping you can tell me where I went wrong:

  • - ~5.5 lbs (pre-trimmed) of Prime Angus grain fed brisket point from https://shalhoob.com/butcher-shop
  • - trimmed as much of the silver skin off as I could
  • - trimmed off hard fat and tried to leave 1/8" to 1/4" of fat
  • - seasoned 24 hours prior to cook with 50/50 coarse black pepper and kosher salt
  • - used Kamado Joe lump charcoal and two medium chucks of mesquite hardwood
  • - ambient outside temperature was low-mid 80s
  • - waited until grill came up to temp and smoke was mostly clear before putting meat on
  • - put meat on fat side down
  • - cooked in Classic III using sloroller, on the lower level rack
  • - cooked with water pan on grill
  • - used Thermopro two probe digital thermometer (1 probe at grill level, 1 probe in thickest part of brisket)
  • - grill temp ranged between 245-270, but mostly 250-260
  • - took ~6.5 hrs to get to 170 internal temp
  • - wrapped in foil at 172
  • - took ~1.5 hrs to get to 203 
  • - at ~203 a wood shish kabob skewer did go through meat, but still felt a little resistance. At this point I pulled it b/c I was concerned about over cooking
  • - kept in foil, wrapped in towel, put in cooler for 1.5 hrs

The brisket had bark and a smoke ring. Pencil thin slice passed pull test. But it was dry and dense.  The attached photos are from the day after the cook and the meat is cold.


Where do I go wrong?






Link to post
Share on other sites

Not sure I should comment on this since I have about a 250 batting average on briskets myself.  Have you verified your thermometers?  8 hours seems a long time to cook a flat at those temperatures.  I've ever done a flat before so that alone should disqualify my opinion.:wacko:

Link to post
Share on other sites

Can't say for sure but I do not use a water pan, season right before going on, goes on right from fridge, and I set it on my upper rack (higher in the dome). 


That looks like a point, and what was the temp at the thinner parts? Since a flat is more thin than thick I typically insert the probe in the middle towards the thinner ends when it is just a flat. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Dry and tough....under cooked. Dry and crumbly....over cooked. 



5 hours ago, burnt_ends said:

Where do I go wrong?


5 hours ago, burnt_ends said:

- at ~203 a wood shish kabob skewer did go through meat, but still felt a little resistance. At this point I pulled it b/c I was concerned about over cooking



Its done when it probes like butter. Not at a certain temp. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Reads like you might have pulled it off too early.


I know hot and fast is en vogue for brisket on other forums, but that type of cook doesn't necessarily take advantage of the better qualities of a ceramic.


Another part of the equation is the wrap. I've never been a fan of the Texas crutch to push through the stall on a Kamado. I'd consider wrapping based on color and let the cooker do the heavy lifting. It might take longer, but you'll probably have more consistent brisket. 

Link to post
Share on other sites

Do I understand you correctly that your main complaint is dryness?

5 hours ago, burnt_ends said:

my brisket turned out dry and dense

Cold brisket is quite dry and dense, no matter what you do. That's why I refrigerate it before slicing, so it slices easily. The secret to brisket is the juice has a lot of fat and gelatin that's solid when cold. 


Which is, perhaps, what I do differently. I always foil, but as a boat to collect fluid expressed as the meat moves through the stall to done. It's not insignificant, about an ounce per pound after skimming fat. Completely jellied when refrigerated, incredibly good as a dipping sauce, or pooled under slices. It really brings the rub flavors to the interior. 


I do the same things with pulled pork, and the fluid's completely re-absorbed. If you shredded it, I bet brisket would do the same. 


Have fun,


Link to post
Share on other sites

One thing to try is to not trim the fat at all.

I know EVERYBODY does it but there's a famous lady pitmaster in central Texas who cooks three hundred packers a week and she just opens the packaging and plops them on the cook grate.

After cooking you can always cut off the fat layer if it offends, but I can't get enough myself and it does trap moisture in the meat.


Link to post
Share on other sites

Popping open the cryovac brisket and plopping it in the smoker offers more room for error since you have so much fat to protect the tip and flat.  But that is a lot of meat for my current family of 3 (couple off to college).  In fact yesterday I cut a Smart and Final cryovac brisket into 3 separate pieces and left most of the fat, but I am sure it will not be as error proof as cooking it whole.  We'll know tomorrow around 4:00 pst:) . On another topic I will be experimenting with the plate-setter/no plate-setter debate.  When I did this in the early 2000's I never used a heat deflector.  Sometimes 3 or 4 pork butts at a time for 36 hours.  As long as the temp was stable at 200 I had no issues.  Except for soot management.  My BGE has the plate setter which I will try on some cooks and not on others.  Place your bets on the outcome of my not so scientific experiment.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Similar Content

    • By sdimartino
      Hey, everyone, new guy here (to both the forum and kamado cooking). My question is about starting up the charcoal. Right now I'm using a chimney starter with newspaper, but I hate the bloom of acrid smoke I get from the paper, so I picked up some paraffin starting cubes. Unfortunately I can't seem to use the cubes with the chimney because they fall through the grate (I have to set the chimney on the grate because I don't really have anywhere else to set it, no concrete on my patio). Can I just start the coals by stacking them in a pile on the grate and sticking a cube in the middle of the pile?
      Or, let me approach this a different way... How do you start your coals up?
    • By Cranky1
      Hi all,
      Just got an Akorn 16820 and mother nature decided to go all cool and wet on me. Looking forward to trying this thing out.
    • By social assassin
      Hi Everyone,
      I’m looking for any tips on how to cook a full packer brisket on my KJ Classic 2.  To date I have only smoked brisket twice; one time each of the Point & the Flat.  After seeing them in person at Costco it doesn’t look like it will fit on my KJ.  How do you make it work?
       I am not sure if I posted this question in the correct thread.
      Take Care,
    • By MurphyBBQ
      Cooking my first brisket on the KJ Classic 2 and had a lot of trouble with thick white smoke. My process below, if anybody can help me find the mistake it would be much appreciated!
      - Loaded KJ with Jealous Devil lump charcoal and mix ~5-7 oak log chunks of medium (?) size. Logs were highly likely kiln dried but I did get them in firewood-like logs from a meat market vs the mass distro grocery store/home improvement bags
      - Used Royal Oak starters and got the lump lit for about 15 minutes, then a couple of the oak chunks caught and I got a decent fire.
      - Closed the top but opened the vent fully to try to let it smoke out and carbonize. Temp jumped pretty quickly to about 350 so I choked it back and got it stable around 260 but the thick white smoke continued for a solid 45+ minutes at which point I had no choice but to start the meat
      - White smoke continued for another hour+ after this, albeit it didnt billow out quite as aggressively. This went on for a couple of hours at least which seemed like an excessively long time.
      Thoughts? Advice?
    • By Redbeard23
      So I am smoking my first brisket on my Kamado Joe Classic II and pretty well following Johns Brisket 101 video from the Kamado Joe YouTube channel. It has been on about 4 hours at 225 degrees and my dome temp was steady until it started to rise about 30 min ago. It stopped about 250 degrees and seems to be holding steady there now. Any advice on why this happened and if it’s okay? Should I try to lower it? If so, what is the best method. Getting good blueish smoke and have been for most of the cook. Any help would be appreciated.
  • Create New...