Jump to content

The Big Green Egg Ceramic Cooker Review


Recommended Posts

The Big Green Egg Review


Here's my review of The Large Big Green EGG that lots of you have been waiting for. I have own my BGE for five years and going on six. I have been using it at least five time a week since I owned it. I also own two large Kamado Joe BBQ has well, so I have lots of experience using these Kamado ceramic cookers. BGE come in the XL, Large, Medium, Small, and mini in size. They also have a large variety of accessories available for the use on the BGE.

The Big Green EGG company was founded in 1974 in Atlanta, Georgia. Has you can see they have been on the market producing ceramic Kamado's for a long period. I found the BGE difficult to put together compared to other cooker so it might be a smart ideal to get the dealer to put it together for you. There's lots of Eggheads out there that worships BGE like a shrine. There is lots of BGE support forums out there with lots of good people on there to help with cooking, sharing recipes, etc...


• 18-inch diameter cooking grid

• Top vent cap is cast iron

• Bottom vent is stainless steel

• Heavy ceramic shell holds heat and stops temperature fluctuations

• Glazed exterior makes it easy to clean

• Spring loaded lid for easy lifting

• Porcelain coated steel cooking grates

• Precisely molded ceramics bonded with a green, nontoxic glazed exterior that won’t fade, discolour or peel

• Weighs 140 pounds

• 255 square inches of cooking surface

• The Large EGG can cook: ◦20-pound turkey

◦ 12 burgers

◦ 6 chickens vertically

◦ 8 steaks

◦ 7 racks of ribs vertically





The Big Green Egg has a cooking temperature range from 0 degree F to 750 degree F but can easily obtain temperatures over 1000 degree F. This BBQ is perfect for smoking to searing steaks. I was able to maintain a temp of 350 degree F for 12 hours without a hitch which is pretty good. This Kamado style cooker is also perfect for baking with the use of the optional plate setter and pizza stone. You can cook indirect with the use of there plate setter. There ceramic isn't has thick as other Kamado style cookers but is of very good quality. The thickness of the ceramic will not affect the taste of the food but will help in retaining internal heat which makes it more efficient!



Indirect set up:


Baking set-up without pizza stone:


Baking with plate setter and Pizza stone set-up:


The cons:

I find that there Temperature gauge is very small which can be hard to read. One think that I really dislike about the BGE is that there factory installed gasket don't last. As soon as you do high temp cooking you will most likely burn the gasket. I replaced mine almost every three months and finally decided to go with a Rutland gasket which will last for a long period. There replacement gasket cost approximately twenty dollars which can add up pretty quick! BGE has known about the issue with their gasket for many years and never went out of there way to find a better gasket material that can withstand the high heat. My question is why did they ever address this issue. I also dislike the size of their casters which I find them small for the weight of the egg. Also the BGE is easy to tip when moving it around with it in the nest so you have to use caution when moving it around. I also find that BGE air flow into there fire box is not has good has there competition. I also find them very costly compared to better Kamado cookers! The upper vent has tendency to fully open when opening the lid so don't forget to re-adjust after closing the lid. This can be prevented by putting the screw of the daisy wheel toward the top




The gasket burn test perform by GrandPas Grub from greeneggers:

Here's what he had to say:

Here is the BGE felt gasket after applying a MAPP torch to the gasket. 15 seconds with a 15 to 18 inch distance.


You can see the full test here and see how order brands gasket faired out for your own education: BGE, Kamado Joe and Nomex Gasket Burn TEST http://www.greeneggers.com/index.php?option=com_simpleboard&func=view&id=1158737&catid=1

The Pro:

Overall it's a pretty good BBQ that produces very good results. I would definitely rate them in the top 3 ceramic Kamado style BBQ's. What I also like about there cooker is that it has a screen on there bottom vent for added fire safety and that it has a rain cap to put out the lump charcoal and to keep the weather out. There ceramic inside the cooker is a very smooth surface which makes it easier to clean and less grease will stick. I also like the fact that there fire box is pre-cut on one side which prevents it's from cracking which lots of other brands have issue with. They also have a very large selection of accessories available and there's lots of custom made accessories available for it has well! They have lots of forums out there to help and assist fellow eggheads.





I would definitely recommend the BGE brand to anyone and I found it a good quality Kamado cooker. But I wish that BGE would finally start listening to there customers and improve the BGE product has per customers recommendation and improve there corporate customer service on the Canadian side of the border. To be dully noted that the customer service for them is A1 in the U.S.

I rate them 3.5 stars out of 5 stars rating. I would definitely rate them a lot higher if they would fixed there gasket issue and improve there products as per customer recommendations.

More info on BGE can be found here: BGE Canada Forum: EGGHEAD and http://www.greeneggers and Facebook The-Big-Green-Egg








In Halifax the BGE's are available from "Sparkling Pool and Spa" on 515 Main Street Dartmouth which has excellent customer service! They can also be reached at (902) 462-8187.


“Note, if you’ve been cooking at temperatures above 300 degrees F, be very careful when opening the lid. First, raise the lid and inch or two and pause to “burp” it before raising the lid completely. This will allow the sudden rush of oxygen to burn safely inside the EGG and not as a flashback which could startle you and possibly cause injury.” (BGE, Big Green Egg, Burping the BGE, Egg, Fireball, grilling | posted in Safety First)

Another good review done by HRMBBQ http://hrmcreativebbq.blogspot.com/2011/11/big-green-egg-review.html

Happy Grilling!


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the very nice review! I would still love to have an egg someday. I got an email that they are having a demo day and I could preorder a Large Egg with Nest, platesetter, side tables, and something else for $825. Is this a good deal in your opinion?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have an XL BGE and absolutely love it (less than 2 weeks old). So far, no issue with the gasket and have done several high temp cooks. I would be interested in your opinion what the top kamado cookers are since you rated BGE only a 3.5 out of 5. The one that I really wanted was the Komado Kamado but I didn't have the almost $4000 and I was kind of worried about whether my deck could support its 500 plus pounds. I want to buy a second ceramic grill - a little smaller to do other cooks at the same time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Now you have me strongly considering buying this thing.....here is what it comes with: Large

Big Green Egg Package

With plateseTer, nest, ash tool, starter

cubes, charcoal, dome temp gauge, dual functon

metal top, DVD, manual, lifetime limited warranty


Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...


got a similar offer for a medium BGE but in indigo color for $700. Are big changes coming to BGE?

My bro had a kamado for 40 years until it cracked (brand unknown). Maybe it could have been repair with refractory cement.

The vision gasket looks like felt. Some other the other aftermarket gaskets are nomex®, but I don't think the nomex® manufacturer endorses using nomex® on high temp use for cooking. Right/Wrong?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 8 years later...

Simply put, the Flame Boss 500 WiFi temperature controller is easy to apply, extremely good reliable, and good price. Being capable of trade your pit temperature and modify settings on line is a lifesaver! Plus, with built in meat temperature alarms, the Flame Boss 200 will ship you a text so that you’ll in no way reduce to rubble some other brisket again.

Professional BBQ’ers located the blanketed flow fan did an top notch process of holding the favored temperature. Even more, the open lid detection prevents the fan from over stoking the fireplace whilst you simply need to peek at your scrumptious creation. A small percentage of best temperature control for big green egg customers stated they did have some hassle putting in place the WiFi. However, once you get it up and running, you’ll be proper to move for years of use.

Almost like dishonest, except there’s no cheating in outside smoking, just precise eats!

A few veteran competition people who smoke additionally pointed out that the Flame Boss three hundred fan became slightly greater efficient than the BBQ Guru – DigiQ DX2. In truth, though, they both use so little energy that a mild difference received’t affect the taste or energy utilization.

Another commonplace subject matter you’ll locate among all Gig Green Egg temperature controllers are failed temperature probes. When you stick a small piece of metal right into a hot hearth for hours at a time, a few are sure to run into troubles. The suitable news is Flame Boss as awesome technical and customer support and will deliver you a new one very quickly.

Overall, in case you’ve got a busy existence and can’t dedicate 15 hours to toddler a brisket, the Flame Boss 500 WiFi is for you. It’ll make your life a hell of plenty less complicated, save you wasting money on overcooked meat, and could

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Create New...